USPatent applicationPatented

Non-magnetic monocomponent color toner and preparation method thereof

Granted 18 Dec 2007 · 1 office action

Life of the application

8 dated events
⤢ drag to zoom2006200820102012201420162018202020222024ProsecutionOwnershipTerm & fees
ProsecutionOwnershipTerm & feeshover for detail · click to open

Abstract

The present invention relates to a non-magnetic monocomponent color toner and a preparing method thereof. In the non-magnetic monocomponent color toner including a toner mother particle, silica and titanium dioxide, the toner mother particle comprises a specific shaped particle size distribution of the charge control agents, and thus, providing non-magnetic monocomponent color toner with a narrow charge distribution and good chargeability. Accordingly, the color toner does not cause contamination in the non-imaging region. Also, because it has superior image density and printing efficiency and significantly improved charge maintenance, it has good long-term stability.

Description

6 parts
›CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION

This application claims priority to Korean patent applications Nos. 10-2004-0002281 filed in the Korean Intellectual Property Office on Jan. 13, 2004 and 10-2004-0106176 filed in the Korean Intellectual Property Office on Dec. 15, 2004, the entire disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference.

›BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

(a) Field of the Invention

The present invention relates to a non-magnetic monocomponent color toner offering superior image density and printing efficiency because of a narrow charge distribution and good chargeability, and having superior long-term stability because of significantly improved charge maintenance, and a preparation method thereof.

(b) Description of the Related Art

Recently, demand for color toner is increasing in the field of electrophotography. Color toner is prepared by kneading and crushing, suspension polymerization, emulsion polymerization, etc. Among them, the kneading and crushing method is mainly used in terms of stability, productivity, and so forth.

In the kneading and crushing method, a binder resin, a colorant, a charge controller, a releasing agent, etc., are melted and kneaded to obtain a mixture. The mixture is cooled and crushed to a desired particle size and classified to obtain a toner. The toner is developed by frictional charging to a positive or negative charge depending on the polarity of the developed electrostatic latent image. Recently, printers adopting electrophotography, in which a laser beam is used as light source, have been leading the market. The demand for compactness, lightness, reliability, and full color is increasing rapidly. Thus, electrophotographic devices having a simple structure and offering high good quality and durability are required. Also, a toner having good printing efficiency and stable developing properties in the long term is required.

In order to satisfy the recent need for higher resolution and better image quality, the particle size of toner is becoming smaller. As the particle size of the toner decreases, the surface area per unit weight of the toner particle increases. As a result, the surface characteristics affect charging and particle characteristics of the toner. As the particle size becomes smaller, the charging characteristic is more affected by the charge control agent. In general, a metal complex, a chromium-containing metal dye, or a quaternary ammonium salt is used for negative charging, and nigrosine or a quaternary ammonium salt is used for positive charging, as the charge control agent. The charge control agent is melted and kneaded along with a binder resin, a wax, a colorant, etc., and crushing and classifying are performed to obtain a toner.

The raw material of the charge control agent may have quite a broad particle size distribution. Although the charge control agent particles may be broken down during melting or kneading, the original particle size determines the characteristics of the charge control agent. If the charge control agent has too large a particle size, the binding ability with the binder resin decreases, so it tends to be separated from the toner during crushing. As a result, many toner particles do not contain the charge control agent and the charge distribution becomes broader, so background contamination or fogging tends to occur. Otherwise, if the charge control agent has too small a particle size, most of the charge control agent particles exist inside the toner, so they do not contribute to improvement in charging characteristics.

Accordingly, it is required to improve binding ability with the binder resin, charge distribution, and charge maintenance by specifying the particle size and distribution of the charge control agent.

›SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present inventors worked for a color toner having a narrow charge distribution and good chargeability, and that is capable of improving charge maintenance. Noticing that the binding ability with the binder resin, charge distribution, charge maintenance, etc., are affected by particle size and distribution of the charge control agent, they completed the present invention by identifying that a toner comprising 10-35 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 50-500 nm and 65-90 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 1-4 μm has superior long-term stability because of uniform charge distribution and good chargeability.

Thus, it is an aspect of the present invention to provide a non-magnetic monocomponent color toner comprising both a toner mother particle comprising a charge control agent having a large particle size and a charge control agent having a small particle size; silica; and titanium dioxide, and a preparing method thereof.

›DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION · 1 of 2

In the following detailed description, the embodiments of the invention have been shown and described, simply by way of illustrating the best mode contemplated by the inventors of carrying out the invention. As will be realized, the present invention can be modified in various respects, all without departing from the invention. Accordingly, the description is to be regarded as illustrative in nature, and not restrictive.

The present invention provides a non-magnetic monocomponent color toner comprising a toner mother particle comprising 10-35 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 50-500 nm, and 65-90 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 1-4 μm; silica; and titanium dioxide.

The present invention also provides a method of preparing a non-magnetic monocomponent color toner comprising the steps of preparing a toner mother particle comprising 10-35 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 50-500 nm and 65-90 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 1-4 μm (step 1); and coating the toner mother particle with silica and titanium dioxide (step 2).

The charge control agent used in the present invention comprises a) 10-35 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 50-500 nm and b) 65-90 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 14 μm. More preferably, it comprises 15-25 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 150-450 nm and b) 75-85 wt % of a charge control agent having a particle size of 14 μm. The charge control agent is preferably comprised at 0.5-5 wt %, more preferably at 1-3 wt %. The silica has an average particle size of 5-50 nm, preferably 10-40 nm. It is preferably comprised at 1.0-3.0 wt %, more preferably at 1.5-2.8 wt %. The titanium dioxide has an average particle size of 0.05-2 μm, preferably 0.1-1.5 μm. It is preferably comprised at 0.2-2.5 wt %, more preferably at 0.5-2 wt %.

Unless specified otherwise, average particle size mentioned in the description of the present invention is number-average particle size.

If the content of the charge control agent having a smaller average particle size is below 10 wt %, a sufficiently uniform charge distribution is not obtained. Otherwise, if it exceeds 35 wt %, the particles having a smaller particle size, which have a much larger specific surface area, penetrate the toner particles, thereby failing to fully function as a charge control agent on the surface of the toner particle. In this case, long-term printing efficiency may deteriorate.

If the content of the charge control agent having a larger average particle size is below 65 wt %, the charge control agents having a larger average particle size tend to concentrate on the surface of the toner particle, thereby failing to offer good chargeability. Otherwise, if it exceeds 90 wt %, it is difficult to obtain uniform charge distribution, and if a lot of the charge control agent particles come into the surface, many of them are separated because they have weaker binding ability with the binder resin than the particles having a smaller particle size. As a result, it is difficult to obtain uniform charge distribution, and background contamination or fogging may occur.

For the charge control agent having a specifically shaped particle size distribution, a metal complex, a nigrosine dye, a triphenylmethane dye, a quaternary ammonium salt, or an organotartar compound such as dibutyl tin oxide, etc. may be used. The metal of the metal complex may be Al, Zr, Zn, Ba, etc. Although such intrinsic property of the charge control agent as positive chargeability or negative chargeability does not change, a narrower charge distribution and a better chargeability can be obtained with a specific particle size distribution.

The toner mother particle also comprises a binder resin, a colorant, and a wax as essential components.

The binder resin may be a styrene such as styrene, chlorostyrene and vinylstyrene; an olefin such as ethylene, propylene, butylene and isoprene; a vinyl ester such as vinyl acetate, vinyl propionate, vinyl benzoate and vinyl lactate; an acrylate or a methacrylate such as methyl acrylate, ethyl acrylate, butyl acrylate, dodecyl acrylate, octyl acrylate, phenyl acrylate, methyl methacrylate, ethyl methacrylate, butyl methacrylate, and dodecyl methacrylate; a vinyl ether such as vinyl methyl ether, vinyl ethyl ether, and vinyl butyl ether; a vinyl ketone such as vinyl methyl ketone, vinyl hexyl ketone, and vinyl isopropenyl ketone; and a mixture thereof.

Preferably, polystyrene, a styrene-alkyl acrylate copolymer, a styrene-alkyl methacrylate copolymer, a styrene-acrylonitrile copolymer, a styrene-butadiene copolymer, a styrene-maleic anhydride copolymer, polyethylene, polypropylene, etc. is used. More preferably, polyester, polyurethane, an epoxy resin, a silicone resin, polyamide, a modified resin, paraffin, etc. is used.

For the colorant, carbon black, a magnetic paint, a dye, or a pigment may be used. For example, a nigrosine dye, aniline blue, charcoal blue, chromium yellow, navy blue, DuPont oil red, methylene blue chloride, phthalocyanine blue, lamp black, rose bengal, C.I. pigment red 48:1, C.I. pigment red 48:4, C.I. pigment red 122, C.I. pigment red 57:1, C.I. pigment red 257, C.I. pigment red 269, C.I. pigment yellow 97, C.I. pigment yellow 12, C.I. pigment yellow 17, C.I. pigment yellow 14, C.I. pigment yellow 13, C.I. pigment yellow 16, C.I. pigment yellow 81, C.I. pigment yellow 126, C.I. pigment yellow 127, C.I. pigment blue 9, C.I. pigment blue 15, C.I. pigment blue 15:1, C.I. pigment blue 15:3, etc. may be used.

An inorganic oxide fine particle such as SiO 2 , TiO 2 , MgO, Al 2 O 3 , MnO, ZnO, Fe 2 O 3 , CaO, BaSO 4 , CeO 2 , K 2 O, Na 2 O, ZrO 2 , CaO.SiO, K 2 O.(TiO 2 ) n and Al 2 O 3 .2SiO 2 hydrophobic-treated with hexamethyldisilazane, dimethyldichlorosilane, octyltrimethoxysilane, etc. may be added to the toner mother particle as a fluidity accelerator. The toner mother particle may further comprise a releasing agent.

›DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION · 2 of 2

The toner mother particle preferably has an average particle size of 10 μm, more preferably 4-10 μm, and most preferably 5-9 μm.

After a toner mother particle is prepared by mixing and kneading the charge control agent, which has a specific shaped particle size distribution, along with a binder resin, a colorant and a wax (releasing agent), silica and titanium oxide particles are added to prepare the non-magnetic monocomponent color toner of the present invention.

The silica preferably has an average particle size of 5-50 nm, preferably 10-40 nm. It is preferably comprised at 1.0-3.0 wt %, more preferably at 1.5-2.8 wt %. The titanium dioxide preferably has an average particle size of 0.05-2 μm, more preferably 0.1-1.5 μm. It is preferably comprised at 0.2-2.5 wt %, more preferably at 0.5-2wt %.

Although the silica and the titanium dioxide may be attached to the surface of the toner mother particle electrostatically, a mechanical mixing treatment using a Henschel mixer, a hybridizer, etc. is preferable. Preferably, the toner mother particle, silica, and titanium dioxide are coated after being mixed at a stirring rate of at least 10 m/s.

The resultant non-magnetic monocomponent color toner preferably has an average particle size of at most 20 μm, more preferably 3-15 μm.

The non-magnetic monocomponent color toner of the present invention offers better long-term image stability than the conventional counterpart. It is also advantageous in offering higher resolution, better printing efficiency, and clearer color. The better effect is attained as the toner particle has the smaller size.

Accordingly, a non-magnetic monocomponent color toner having good chargeability, charge maintenance, and clear color can be prepared according to the present invention. The toner is more environmentally friendly and can offer a more stable image while satisfying the need of higher resolution.

Hereinafter, the present invention is described in more detail through examples. However, the following examples are only for the understanding of the present invention and they do not limit the present invention.

›EXAMPLE 1

1) Preparation of Toner Mother Particle

94 parts by weight of polyester resin (molecular weight=2.5×10 5 ), 4 parts by weight of phthalocyanine P.BI.15:3, 1 part by weight of a metal-containing azo salt (charge control agent C) comprising 30 wt % of a particle having a particle size of 50-500 nm and 70 wt % of a particle having a particle size of 1-4 μm, and 4 parts by weight of polypropylene having a small molecular weight were mixed using a Henschel mixer. The mixture was melted and kneaded at 165° C. using a twin melt kneader, crushed using a jet mil crusher, and classified using an air classifier to obtain a toner mother particle having a volume-average particle size of 7.5 μm.

2) Preparation of Non-magnetic Monocomponent Color Toner

2.0 wt % of silica having an average particle size of 17 nm and 1.0 wt % of titanium dioxide particle having an average particle size of 0.1 μm were mixed with 100 parts by weight of the prepared toner mother particle while stirring for 3 minutes at a tip speed of at least 10 m/s using a Henschel mixer to obtain a non-magnetic monocomponent color toner.

EXAMPLES 2-182

Non-magnetic monocomponent color-toners were prepared in the same manner of Example 1, except that charge control agents presented in Table 1 below, silica presented in Table 2 below, and titanium dioxide presented in Table 3 below were used according to the composition given in Table 4 below.

COMPARATIVE EXAMPLES 1-270

Non-magnetic monocomponent color toners were prepared in the same manner of Example 1, except that charge control agents presented in Table 1 above, silica presented in Table 2 above, and titanium dioxide presented in Table 3 above were used according to the composition given in Table 5 below. That is to say, charge control agents not having a specific shaped particle size were used in the Comparative Examples.

TESTING EXAMPLE 1

5,000 sheets of paper was printed with each of the non-magnetic monocomponent color toner prepared in Examples 1-182 and Comparative Examples 1-270 using a contact type of non-magnetic monocomponent development printer (HP 4600, Hewlett-Packard) at normal temperature and humidity (20° C., 55% RH). Image density, printing efficiency, and long-term stability were tested. The results are given in Table 6 below.

1) Image Density (I.D.)

Solid area was measured using a Macbeth reflectance densitometer RD918.

∘: Image density was 1.4 or above.

Δ: Image density was 1.2-1.4.

×: Image density was 1.0-1.2.

2) Printing efficiency

Of the 5,000 sheets of paper, printing efficiency was calculated by counting the number of wasted sheets per each 500 sheets.

{circle around (∘)}: Printing efficiency was 80% or over.

∘: Printing efficiency was 70-80%.

Δ: Printing efficiency was 60-70%.

×: Printing efficiency was 50-60%.

3) Long-term stability

It was confirmed if I.D. and printing efficiency were maintained after printing 5,000 sheets.

A: I.D. was 1.4 or over and printing efficiency was 80% or over.

B: I.D. was 1.3-1.4 and printing efficiency was 70-80%.

C: I.D. was 1.2-1.3 and printing efficiency was 60-70%.

D: I.D. was 1.0-1.2 and printing efficiency was 50-60%.

As seen in Table 6 and Table 7, when a charge control agent having a specific shaped particle size distribution was used, as in the present invention, image density, printing efficiency, and long-term stability were superior. This is because the charge control agent particle having a larger particle size tends to be present on the surface, while the charge control agent particle having a smaller particle size does not because of a stronger binding ability with the binder resin.

As apparent from the above description, the non-magnetic monocomponent color toner of the present invention, which comprises a charge control agent having a specific shaped particle size distribution, enables excellent functioning as a charge control agent because the charge control agent particle having a smaller particle size has good binding ability with the binder resin and the charge control agent having a larger particle size tends to be present on the surface. The toner comprising such a charge control agent offers higher resolution because of good chargeability and ensures long-term stability because of uniform charge distribution.

While the present invention has been described in detail with reference to exemplary embodiments, those skilled in the art will appreciate that various modifications and substitutions can be made thereto without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention as set forth in the appended claims.

›Tables in the description — 7
TABLE 1 — Average particle size
Compoundsdistribution
Charge controlMetal-containing azo salt50-500nm
agent A
Charge controlMetal-containing azo salt1-4μm
agent B
Charge controlMetal-containing azo salt50-500nm, 30 wt %;
agent C1-4μm, 70 wt %
Charge controlQuaternary ammonium salt50-500nm
agent D
Charge controlQuaternary ammonium salt1-4μm
agent E
Charge controlQuaternary ammonium salt50-500nm, 30 wt %;
agent F1-4μm, 70 wt %
Charge controlZinc salicylate50-500nm
agent G
Charge controlZinc salicylate1-4μm
agent H
Charge controlZinc salicylate50-500nm, 30 wt %;
agent I1-4μm, 70 wt %
Charge controlBoron complex50-500nm
agent J
Charge controlBoron complex1-4μm
agent K
Charge controlBoron complex50-500nm, 30 wt %;
agent L1-4μm, 70 wt %
Charge controlMetal-containing azo salt50-500nm, 15 wt %;
agent M1-4μm, 85 wt %
Charge controlQuaternary ammonium salt50-500nm, 20 wt %;
agent N1-4μm, 80 wt %
Charge controlBoron complex50-500nm, 10 wt %;
agent O1-4μm, 90 wt %
Charge controlZinc salicylate30-300nm, 85 wt %;
agent P1-4μm, 15 wt %
Charge controlMetal-containing azo salt30-300nm, 90 wt %;
agent Q1-4μm, 10 wt %
Charge controlQuaternary ammonium salt30-300nm, 85 wt %;
agent R1-4μm, 15 wt %
Charge controlBoron complex30-300nm, 85 wt %;
agent S1-4μm, 15 wt %
TABLE 2 — Hydrophobic surface
Specific surface area (m 2 /g)* 1treatment
Silica A7Dimethyl silicone oil
Silica B17Dimethyl silicone oil
Silica C50HMDS* 2
* 1 BET measurement values
* 2 HMDS = hexamethyldisilazane
TABLE 3 — Average particle size (μm)
Titanium dioxide A0.1
Titanium dioxide B1.1
Titanium dioxide C1.6
TABLE 4
ExampleCharge control agent(wt %)Silica (wt %)Titanium oxide(wt %)
2Charge control agent C1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
3Charge control agent C1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
4Charge control agent C1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
5Charge control agent C1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
6Charge control agent C1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
7Charge control agent C1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.5
8Charge control agent C1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
9Charge control agent C1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
10Charge control agent C1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C2.0
11Charge control agent C1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
12Charge control agent C1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
13Charge control agent C1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.5
14Charge control agent C1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
15Charge control agent C1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
16Charge control agent C1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
17Charge control agent C1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
18Charge control agent C1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
19Charge control agent C1.0Silica B3.0Titanium oxide C2.0
20Charge control agent C3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
21Charge control agent C3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
22Charge control agent C3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
23Charge control agent C3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
24Charge control agent C3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
25Charge control agent C3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
26Charge control agent C3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
27Charge control agent C3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
28Charge control agent C3.0Silica C3.0Titanium oxide C2.0
29Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
30Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
31Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
32Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
33Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
34Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
35Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
36Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
37Charge control agent F3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
38Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
39Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
40Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
41Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
42Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
43Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
44Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
45Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
46Charge control agent F3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
47Charge control agent F3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A0.5
48Charge control agent F3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
49Charge control agent F3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A2.0
50Charge control agent F3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
51Charge control agent F3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
52Charge control agent F3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
53Charge control agent F3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
54Charge control agent F3.0Silica C3.0Titanium oxide C1.0
55Charge control agent F3.0Silica C3.0Titanium oxide C2.0
56Charge control agent I1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
57Charge control agent I1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
58Charge control agent I1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
59Charge control agent I1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
60Charge control agent I1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
61Charge control agent I1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
62Charge control agent I1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.5
63Charge control agent I3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
64Charge control agent I3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
65Charge control agent I3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
66Charge control agent I3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A1.5
67Charge control agent I3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
68Charge control agent I3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
69Charge control agent I3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
70Charge control agent I3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B1.5
71Charge control agent I3.0Silica B3.0Titanium oxide C1.0
72Charge control agent I3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A2.0
73Charge control agent L1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
74Charge control agent L1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.5
75Charge control agent L1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
76Charge control agent L1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.5
77Charge control agent L1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
78Charge control agent L1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.5
79Charge control agent L1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide A0.5
80Charge control agent L1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide B0.5
81Charge control agent L1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C0.5
82Charge control agent L1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide A1.5
83Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A0.5
84Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
85Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A2.5
86Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
87Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
88Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B2.5
89Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
90Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
91Charge control agent L1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
92Charge control agent L2.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
93Charge control agent L1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A0.5
94Charge control agent L3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A1.5
95Charge control agent L3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A2.5
96Charge control agent L3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
97Charge control agent L3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
98Charge control agent L3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
99Charge control agent L3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
100Charge control agent L2.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
101Charge control agent L2.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
102Charge control agent M1.0Silica A0.5Titanium oxide A0.5
103Charge control agent M1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
104Charge control agent M1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
105Charge control agent M1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
106Charge control agent M1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
107Charge control agent M1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
108Charge control agent M1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
109Charge control agent M1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
110Charge control agent M1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C2.5
111Charge control agent M1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
112Charge control agent M2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
113Charge control agent M2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
114Charge control agent M2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
115Charge control agent M2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
116Charge control agent M2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
117Charge control agent M2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
118Charge control agent M2.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
119Charge control agent M2.0Silica B3.0Titanium oxide C2.0
120Charge control agent M2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
121Charge control agent M2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
122Charge control agent M2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
123Charge control agent M2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
124Charge control agent M3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
125Charge control agent M3.0Silica C3.0Titanium oxide B2.0
126Charge control agent M3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
127Charge control agent M3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
128Charge control agent M3.0Silica C3.0Titanium oxide C2.5
129Charge control agent N1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
130Charge control agent N1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
131Charge control agent N1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
132Charge control agent N1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
133Charge control agent N1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
134Charge control agent N1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
135Charge control agent N1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
136Charge control agent N1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C1.0
137Charge control agent N1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
138Charge control agent N2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
139Charge control agent N2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
140Charge control agent N2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.5
141Charge control agent N2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
142Charge control agent N2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
143Charge control agent N2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
144Charge control agent N2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
145Charge control agent N2.0Silica B3.0Titanium oxide C1.0
146Charge control agent N2.0Silica B3.0Titanium oxide C2.0
147Charge control agent N2.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A0.5
148Charge control agent N3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
149Charge control agent N3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
150Charge control agent N4.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
151Charge control agent N4.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
152Charge control agent N4.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
153Charge control agent N5.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
154Charge control agent N5.0Silica C3.0Titanium oxide C1.0
155Charge control agent N5.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
156Charge control agent O1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
157Charge control agent O1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
158Charge control agent O1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
159Charge control agent O1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
160Charge control agent O1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
161Charge control agent O1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
162Charge control agent O2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
163Charge control agent O2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
164Charge control agent O2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
165Charge control agent O1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
166Charge control agent O2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
167Charge control agent O2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
168Charge control agent O2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
169Charge control agent O2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
170Charge control agent O2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
171Charge control agent O2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
172Charge control agent O2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
173Charge control agent O2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.5
174Charge control agent O2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
175Charge control agent O3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
176Charge control agent O3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
177Charge control agent O3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
178Charge control agent O4.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
179Charge control agent O4.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
180Charge control agent O4.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
181Charge control agent O5.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
182Charge control agent O5.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
TABLE 5 — Comparative
ExampleCharge control agent(wt %)Silica(wt %)Titanium oxide (wt %)
1Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
2Charge control agent A2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
3Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
4Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
5Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
6Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
7Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
8Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
9Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
10Charge control agent A1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
11Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
12Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
13Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
14Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
15Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
16Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
17Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
18Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
19Charge control agent A1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
20Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
21Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
22Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
23Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
24Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
25Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
26Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
27Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
28Charge control agent A3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
29Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
30Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
31Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
32Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
33Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
34Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
35Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
36Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
37Charge control agent B3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
38Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
39Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
40Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
41Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
42Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
43Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
44Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
45Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
46Charge control agent B3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
47Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A0.5
48Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
49Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A2.0
50Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
51Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
52Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
53Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
54Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
55Charge control agent B3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
56Charge control agent D1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C3.0
57Charge control agent D1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
58Charge control agent D1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
59Charge control agent D1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
60Charge control agent D1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
61Charge control agent D1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
62Charge control agent D1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
63Charge control agent D3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
64Charge control agent D3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
65Charge control agent D3.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
66Charge control agent D3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A1.5
67Charge control agent D3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
68Charge control agent D3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
69Charge control agent D3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
70Charge control agent D3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B1.5
71Charge control agent D3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
72Charge control agent D3.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A2.0
73Charge control agent E1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
74Charge control agent E1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.5
75Charge control agent E1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
76Charge control agent E1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.5
77Charge control agent E1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
78Charge control agent E1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
79Charge control agent E1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide A0.5
80Charge control agent E1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide B0.5
81Charge control agent E1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C0.5
82Charge control agent E1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide A1.5
83Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A0.5
84Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
85Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A2.0
86Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
87Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
88Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
89Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
90Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
91Charge control agent E1.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
92Charge control agent E2.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
93Charge control agent E1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A0.5
94Charge control agent E3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A1.5
95Charge control agent E3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A2.0
96Charge control agent E3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
97Charge control agent E3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
98Charge control agent E3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
99Charge control agent E3.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
100Charge control agent E2.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
101Charge control agent E2.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
102Charge control agent G2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
103Charge control agent G2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
104Charge control agent G2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
105Charge control agent G2.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
106Charge control agent G2.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
107Charge control agent G2.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
108Charge control agent G2.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C0.5
109Charge control agent G2.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C1.0
110Charge control agent G2.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C2.0
111Charge control agent G2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
112Charge control agent G2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
113Charge control agent G2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
114Charge control agent G2.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
115Charge control agent G2.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
116Charge control agent G2.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
117Charge control agent G2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
118Charge control agent G2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
119Charge control agent G2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B1.5
120Charge control agent G2.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
121Charge control agent G2.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
122Charge control agent H2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
123Charge control agent H2.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
124Charge control agent H2.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide A2.0
25Charge control agent H2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
126Charge control agent H2.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
127Charge control agent H2.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide B2.0
128Charge control agent H2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
129Charge control agent H2.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
130Charge control agent H2.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C2.0
131Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
132Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
133Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
134Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
135Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
136Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
137Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
138Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
139Charge control agent H2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.5
140Charge control agent H2.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
141Charge control agent H2.0Silica B3.0Titanium oxide A3.0
142Charge control agent H2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
143Charge control agent H2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
144Charge control agent H2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
145Charge control agent H2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
146Charge control agent H2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
147Charge control agent H2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
148Charge control agent H2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C3.0
149Charge control agent K2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
150Charge control agent K2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
151Charge control agent K2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
152Charge control agent K2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
153Charge control agent K2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
154Charge control agent K2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B3.0
155Charge control agent K2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
156Charge control agent K2.0Silica A5.0Titanium oxide C1.0
157Charge control agent K2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C3.0
158Charge control agent K1.0Silica A3.0Titanium oxide C3.0
159Charge control agent K1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
160Charge control agent K1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
161Charge control agent K1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.5
162Charge control agent K1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
163Charge control agent K1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
164Charge control agent K1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B3.0
165Charge control agent K1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
166Charge control agent K1.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
167Charge control agent K1.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
168Charge control agent K1.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C3.0
169Charge control agent J2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
170Charge control agent J2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
171Charge control agent J2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
172Charge control agent J2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
173Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
174Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
175Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
176Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
177Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
178Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B3.0
179Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0 wTitanium oxide C1.0
180Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
181Charge control agent P1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C3.0
182Charge control agent P1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
183Charge control agent P1.0Silica B5.0Titanium oxide B1.0
184Charge control agent P2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
185Charge control agent P2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
186Charge control agent P2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A3.0
187Charge control agent P2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
188Charge control agent P2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
189Charge control agent P2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B3.0
190Charge control agent P2.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
191Charge control agent P3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
192Charge control agent P4.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C3.0
193Charge control agent P8.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
194Charge control agent Q1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
195Charge control agent Q1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
196Charge control agent Q1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
197Charge control agent Q1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
198Charge control agent Q1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
199Charge control agent Q1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B3.0
200Charge control agent Q1.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
201Charge control agent Q1.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
202Charge control agent Q1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C3.0
203Charge control agent Q1.0Silica A2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
204Charge control agent Q2.0Silica A5.0Titanium oxide B1.0
205Charge control agent Q2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
206Charge control agent Q2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
207Charge control agent Q2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A3.0
208Charge control agent Q2.0Silica B5.0Titanium oxide B1.0
209Charge control agent Q2.0Silica B5.0Titanium oxide B2.0
210Charge control agent Q2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B3.0
211Charge control agent Q2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
212Charge control agent Q3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
213Charge control agent Q5.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C3.0
214Charge control agent Q6.0Silica B2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
215Charge control agent Q3.0Silica C1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
216Charge control agent R1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
217Charge control agent R1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
218Charge control agent R1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
219Charge control agent R1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
220Charge control agent R1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
221Charge control agent R1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
222Charge control agent R1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
223Charge control agent R1.0Silica A5.0Titanium oxide C1.0
224Charge control agent R1.0Silica A6.0Titanium oxide C3.0
225Charge control agent R1.0Silica B6.0Titanium oxide A0.5
226Charge control agent R1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
227Charge control agent R2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
228Charge control agent R2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
229Charge control agent R2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
230Charge control agent R2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B5.0
231Charge control agent R6.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
232Charge control agent R5.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
233Charge control agent S1.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
234Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A0.5
235Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A1.0
236Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide A2.0
237Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B0.5
238Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B1.0
239Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide B2.0
240Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C0.5
241Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C1.0
242Charge control agent S1.0Silica C2.0Titanium oxide C2.0
243Charge control agent S1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A0.5
244Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
245Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide A2.0
246Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
247Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
248Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
249Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
250Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
251Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
252Charge control agent S2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
253Charge control agent S3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5 w
254Charge control agent S3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
255Charge control agent S3.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
256Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B0.5
257Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B1.0
258Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
259Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
260Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
261Charge control agent S2.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
262Charge control agent S2.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide B2.0
263Charge control agent S5.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
264Charge control agent S6.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C1.0
265Charge control agent S10.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide C2.0
266Charge control agent R1.0Silica A1.0Titanium oxide C0.5
267Charge control agent R5.0Silica A5.0Titanium oxide C3.0
268Charge control agent R1.0Silica A5.0Titanium oxide C3.0
269Charge control agent R1.0Silica B0.5Titanium oxide A0.5
270Charge control agent R5.0Silica B1.0Titanium oxide A1.0
TABLE 6
ImagePrintingLong-term
Exampledensityefficiencystability
1∘⊚A
2∘⊚A
3∘⊚A
4∘⊚A
5∘⊚A
6∘⊚A
7∘∘A
8∘⊚A
9∘⊚A
10∘⊚A
11∘⊚A
12∘⊚A
13∘⊚B
14∘⊚A
15∘⊚A
16∘⊚A
17∘⊚A
18∘⊚A
19∘⊚A
20∘⊚A
21∘⊚A
22∘⊚A
23∘⊚A
24∘⊚A
25∘⊚A
26∘⊚A
27∘⊚A
28∘∘A
29∘⊚A
30∘⊚A
31∘⊚A
32∘⊚A
33∘⊚A
34∘⊚A
35∘⊚A
36∘⊚A
37∘⊚A
38∘⊚A
39∘⊚A
40∘⊚A
41∘⊚A
42∘⊚A
43∘∘B
44∘⊚A
45∘⊚A
46∘∘B
47∘⊚A
48∘⊚A
49∘∘B
50∘⊚A
51∘⊚A
52∘⊚B
53∘⊚A
54∘⊚A
55∘∘A
56∘∘A
57∘⊚A
58∘⊚A
59∘⊚A
60∘⊚A
61∘⊚A
62∘∘A
63∘⊚A
64∘∘B
65∘⊚A
66∘⊚A
67∘⊚A
68∘∘B
69∘⊚A
70∘⊚A
71∘⊚A
72∘⊚A
73∘⊚A
74∘⊚A
75∘⊚A
76∘⊚A
77∘⊚A
78∘⊚A
79Δ⊚B
80∘⊚A
81∘⊚A
82∘⊚A
83∘⊚A
84∘⊚A
85∘⊚A
86∘⊚A
87∘⊚A
88∘∘A
89∘⊚A
90∘⊚A
91∘⊚A
92∘⊚A
93∘⊚A
94∘⊚A
95Δ⊚A
96∘⊚A
97∘⊚A
98∘⊚A
99∘⊚A
100∘⊚A
101∘∘B
101∘⊚A
102∘⊚A
103∘⊚A
104∘⊚A
105∘⊚A
106∘⊚A
107∘⊚A
108∘⊚A
109∘⊚A
110∘⊚A
111∘⊚A
112∘⊚A
113∘⊚A
114∘⊚A
115∘⊚A
116∘⊚A
117∘⊚A
118∘⊚A
119∘⊚A
120∘⊚A
121∘⊚A
122∘⊚A
123∘⊚A
124∘⊚A
125∘⊚B
126∘⊚A
127∘⊚A
128∘∘A
129∘⊚A
130∘⊚A
131∘⊚A
132∘⊚A
133∘⊚A
134∘⊚A
135∘⊚A
136∘⊚A
137∘⊚A
138∘⊚A
139∘⊚A
140∘⊚A
141∘⊚A
142∘⊚A
143∘∘B
144∘⊚A
145∘⊚A
146∘∘B
47∘⊚A
148∘⊚A
149∘∘B
150∘⊚A
151∘⊚A
152∘∘B
153∘⊚A
154∘∘A
155∘⊚A
156∘∘A
157∘⊚A
158∘⊚A
159∘⊚A
160∘⊚A
161∘⊚A
162∘⊚A
163∘⊚A
164∘⊚A
165∘⊚A
166∘⊚A
167∘⊚A
168∘⊚A
169∘⊚A
170∘⊚A
171∘⊚A
172∘⊚A
173∘⊚B
174∘⊚A
175∘⊚A
176∘⊚A
177∘⊚A
178∘∘A
179∘∘A
180∘∘A
181∘∘A
182∘⊚A
TABLE 7
ComparativeImagePrintingLong-term
Exampledensityefficiencystability
1xxD
2xΔC
3ΔxD
4xxD
5xxD
6ΔxD
7xxD
8xxC
9ΔxD
10xxD
11xxC
12ΔxD
13xxD
14xxC
15xxD
16xxD
17xxC
18ΔxD
19xxD
20xxD
21xxD
22xΔD
23xxD
24xxD
25xxD
26xxC
27xxD
28xΔD
29xxD
30xxD
31xΔD
32xxD
33xxD
34xΔD
35xxD
36xxD
37xΔD
38xxD
39xxD

Claims as granted

8 claims

Log in to read the claims of this application.

Log in to unlock

Classifications

5 codes
IPC · International Patent Classification
Section G — Physics
  • G03G9/087
  • G03G9/08
  • G03G9/097
USPC · US Patent Classification
430/108.6430/137.18

Claim changes

Soon
Coming soonHow the claims changed between publication and grant

See which claims were amended, added or cancelled during examination, with every added and removed word marked.

AmendedAddedCancelledUnchanged

The published claims of this application are not paired with the granted ones in what we hold.

File wrapper

⤢ drag to zoomJan 2005Jul 2005Jan 2006Jul 2006Jan 2007Jul 2007Jan 2008USPTOApplicantNon-final rejectionResponse after non-finalNotice of allowance
USPTOApplicanthover for detail · click to open
Pendency
2.9 y
1,070 days filing → grant
Office actions
1
non-final + final
Responses
1
no RCE
Examiner
John L Goodrow
art unit 1756 · TC 1700
Citations: 13 back · 0 forward

See the full prosecution history — every USPTO and applicant action on this file, in order.

Log in to unlock

Documents

Log in to open the documents of this file: the application as filed, every office action and response, the notice of allowance.

Log in to unlock

Chain of title

⤢ drag to zoom2006200820102012201420162018202020222024Owner 1
Titlehover for detail · click to open

See the full assignment history — every owner this patent has passed through, with recordation dates and reel/frame numbers.

Log in to unlock