USPatentGranted
P3

Limoneira seedless

Granted 20 Mar 2007 · 2 office actions

Assignee: Limoneira Company

Law firm: Law firm · Log in to unlock

Attorney: Attorney · Log in to unlock

Inventors: Nigel Grech, Ercan Ekenler · Examiner: Kent L. Bell · AU 1661 · TC 1600

Life of the patent

3 dated events
⤢ drag to zoomJan 2005Apr 2005Jul 2005Oct 2005Jan 2006Apr 2006Jul 2006Oct 2006Jan 2007Apr 2007Prosecution
Prosecutionhover for detail · click to open

Abstract

A new and distinct cultivar of seedless lemon tree named ‘Limoneira Seedless’ characterized by early bearing in August through to March in the inland citrus areas of South East Turkey and Riverside, Calif. The trees can be induced to flower by irrigation stress in summer, resulting in a late spring crop of lemons. It is further characterized by being commercially seedless. The fruit has acceptable rind thickness, acid-sugar ratios and color. The skin has a smooth texture. The fruit has an average juice content of 30-40% at harvest. The fruit shape is typically round to slightly oval elliptical.

Description

12 parts
›Citrus limon. Variety denomination: ‘Limoneira Seedless’

Citrus limon.

Variety denomination: ‘Limoneira Seedless’.

›BACKGROUND OF THE NEW VARIETY

The present invention refers to a new variety of lemon which will hereinafter be denominated as the ‘Limoneira Seedless’ lemon tree. The ‘Limoneira Seedless’ tree produces commercially seedless lemon fruit, bearing in August through to March in the inland citrus areas of South East Turkey and Riverside, Calif. The ‘Limoneira Seedless’ trees can be induced to flower by irrigation stress in the summer, resulting in production of a late spring crop of lemons. The skin has a smooth texture. The fruit has acceptable rind thickness, acid-sugar ratios and color, and has an average juice content of 30-40% at harvest.

In the development of new commercial fruit varieties, specific characteristics provide a premium on those fruit varieties that mature early or late in the growing season. In general, early varieties tend to lack size, flavor and color. Therefore in order for a fruit to be a commercial success, the fruit must be of good size, good color, and also have good holding/storage and shipping characteristics. In addition, the date of maturing must be different from other similar fruit. This new invention meets all of the aforementioned criteria and therefore would be of commercial appeal to the consumer.

›ORIGIN AND ASEXUAL REPRODUCTION OF THE NEW VARIETY

The invention (variety) comprises a new and distinct variety of a seedless lemon plant named ‘Limoneira Seedless’. The new cultivar is a selection from an old line nucellar block of unknown parentage, but probably the result of a hybrid between a ‘Femminello’ group lemon and the ‘Interdonato’ lemon varieties. The selection was discovered in 1998 by the inventors in Adana, Turkey (approximately 350° E, 370° 15′ N). The new cultivar was subsequently asexually reproduced by the inventors in 1999 by bud grafting on to ‘Sour Orange’ root stock (200 trees in total). The resulting trees were experimentally evaluated. The resulting tree growth was medium to strong with no bud union abnormalities being noted on the ‘Sour Orange’ rootstock. An additional 10 trees were asexually reproduced by the inventors in 2003 by bud grafting on to ‘Sour Orange’ root stock and grown in Riverside, Calif. The inventors carefully compared all of the asexually reproduced trees with the originally discovered tree including the fruit and found they are identical in all respects. The instant tree reproduces true to type in successive generations of such asexual reproductions.

›SUMMARY OF THE NEW VARIETY

The ‘Limoneira Seedless’ is particularly characterized by being commercially seedless and an early bearing variety, maturing when grown in the inland citrus areas of southeast Turkey. The season for the ‘Limoneira Seedless’ lemon in southeastern Turkey and Riverside, Calif. is from August to March. In comparison, the season for the locally grown lemon ‘Kutiken’ lemon (unpatented) in southeastern Turkey is November to February, and that of the ‘Interdonato’ (unpatented) in southeastern Turkey is September to February. The acid to sugar ratios and the juice content for the ‘Limoneira Seedless’ are similar to commercially grown lemons. The trees exhibit acceptable tolerance to cold and to the malady known as Mal secco, a fungal disease of serious importance in the Mediterranean citrus regions.

›BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a color photograph showing a front perspective view of three specimens of typical whole fruit of the present invention harvested in November 2002.

FIG. 2 is a color photograph showing a typical transverse cut section of the fruit of FIG. 1 .

FIG. 3 is a color photograph showing another typical transverse cut section of fruit of the present invention.

FIG. 4 is a color photograph showing a typical longitudinal cut section of fruit of the present invention.

FIG. 5 is a color photograph showing a typical terminal branch bloom development and leaf morphology for the present invention.

FIG. 6 is a color photograph showing a typical terminal fruit development of the present invention.

FIG. 7 is another color photograph showing a typical terminal fruit development of the present invention.

FIG. 8 is a color photograph showing the appearance of a whole tree of the present invention during the fall.

FIG. 9 is a color photograph showing of a branch of the present invention with small thorns.

FIG. 10 is a color composite photograph showing various plant organs (fruit, leaves, flowers and stems) of the present invention as produced in California.

FIG. 11 is a color photograph of the present invention showing a fully open flower.

FIG. 12 is a color photograph of the present invention showing the various stages of floral development as well as color changes.

›DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Referring more specifically to the horticultural details of the new and distinct variety of lemon trees, the following descriptions have been observed on a 4 th year tree under the ecological conditions prevailing at the origin orchard which is located in Adana, Turkey, as well as in Riverside, Calif. Color references are to the Dictionary of Color by Maerz and Paul, First Edition published in 1930. Common colors are also employed.

›TREE

Size: Medium, for 4 th year tree.

Height.— 10 feet. Width.— 10 feet at drip line.

Shape: Upright, effuse growth habit when grown on Sour Orange rootstock.

Growth: Dense; vigorous branches tend to grow out, upward beyond trees' general periphery; abundant axillary and accessory bud development.

Vigor: Medium to strong.

Productivity: Very good for 4 th year tree with regular bearing; fruit produced predominantly inside the canopy resulting in less fruit scaring.

›TRUNK

Immediately above the rootstock interface on sour orange:

Size: Circumference of 12-16 inches, 18 inches above ground.

Surface texture: Smooth.

Color: 4 year old tree, Andover green (23-E-2).

Lenticels: Many.

›BRANCHES

Size: Scaffold (structural) branches, circumference of 10-12 inches; Secondary branches (on which fruit bearing branches are borne) circumference of 4-6 inches.

Angle of branches extending from main trunk: Average between about 30° and about 50°.

Color of branches over 2 years old: Andover green (23-E-2).

Color of branches less than 2 years old: Brunswick green, LT P (22-L-10).

Thorns: Persistent during growth but are reduced in number as the tree ages. On grafted trees the branches have small thorns particularly evident during the first three years. The thorns are on the apical side of the leaf petiole. See FIG. 9 .

Number.— 9-12 thorns per foot on branches less than 2 years old; 0-6 thorns per foot on branches over 2 years old. Size length.— 8-10 mm (0.32-0.4 in.). Width at base.— 2-3 mm (0.08-0.12 in.). A typical observed thorn has an average length of about 9 mm (0.36 in) and an average width at the base of about 2.5 mm (0.1 in.).

›LEAVES

The leaves are alternate, unifoliate with distinct articulation between the petiole and leaf blade. They exhibit a distinctly curvate morphology with undulation, and are without basal wings.

Size: Medium.

Length.— 75-100 mm (2.95-3.94 in.). Width.— 50-60 mm (1.97-2.36 in.).

Texture: Smooth. Shape: Elliptically oval to oblong. Margin: Serrated. Apex: Mild crenation to rounded. Base: Narrowed. Edges: Distinctly smoother towards the basal leaf end. Marginal oil cells: Many 12 per linear cm; oil cells are ovoid and raised. Color: Mature leaves glossy.

Upper surface. —Wintergreen English ivy + (23-A-12). Lower surface. —Fern (21-I-7). Petioles. —No wings (characteristic of true lemon). Length. —Less than 7-12 mm (0.28-0.48 in.). Diameter. —Less than 3 mm (0.12 in.). Color. —Apple green (19-J-6).

Venation: Distinct, pinnately reticulated. Midvein: Width at base, 1-2 mm (0.04-0.08 in.); Width at apex, 0.3 mm-0.4 mm (0.012-0.016 in.). Color: Wintergreen English ivy + (23-A-12).

›FLOWERS

The flowers are large and complete. Flower buds have pink anthocyanin coloration during early development, but lose the pigmentation by anthesis. Flowers are borne in multiple clusters and have an average number of stamens (about 20) with complete style development. Anther color is pale yellow to yellow. Pollen fertility is low as indicated by the observation that only 3-5% of the pollen grains were stained with acetocarmine in a test conducted on this variety. The flowers have a sweet pleasing citrus fragrance.

Flower buds:

Shape.— 10 days prior to anthesis, slightly ovoid, 10 mm (0.4 in.) diameter; 1-2 days prior to flowering, elongated cone, 10 mm (0.4 in.) diameter, 20 mm (0.8 in.) length.

Calyx: 4-5 sepals, fused forming a cup-like calyx.

Exterior surface color. —Calliste green (19-L-6). Lobe tips are blunt but with apiculate tips.

Date of normal first bloom: Southeast Turkey: First bloom: about March 15 th ; end bloom about April 15 th Riverside, Calif.: First bloom about April 1 st , end bloom about April 20 th . Flowers: Small — in clusters of three to five. See FIGS. 5 and 10 .

Diameter when fully opened.— 25-30 mm (1-1.2 in.). Bloom. —E.g. quantity — abundant (typical of a lemon) non-alternate bearing.

Petals: 4-5, acute tips.

Size. —Medium to large (compared to other citrus species). Length: 12-18 mm (0.48-0.72 in.). Width: 6-8 mm (0.24-0.32 in.). Form. —Narrow, linear, slightly oblong. Color. —Adaxial surface — white (1-A-1). Abaxial surface — pink (2-F-6). Claws. —None. Petal margins. —Smooth, pointed at tips (acute). Pedicel.— 4-6 mm (0.16-0.24 in.) average. Color: Sea green (19-K-6). Sepals. —Color: Calliste green (19-L-6). Shape: blunt at tips. Typical width at base: 5 mm (0.2 in.). Typical length: 2-3 mm (0.08-0.12 in.). Margin — smooth. Stamen. —Number: 14-20, with completely style development. Filament: white (10-A-1). Anthers: 2-3 mm (0.08-0.12 in.) length; 1-2 mm (0.04-0.08 in.) width. Color: Aureolin P (10-L-2). Pistil. —Stigma: ovoid shape, 3-4 mm (0.12-0.16 in.) diameter; Color: Pineapple (11-J-2). Style: 8-10 mm (0.32-0.4 in.) length; 2-3 mm (0.08-0.12 in.) wide; Color: Sea foam Y (17-C-2). Ovary: 6-8 mm (0.24-0.32 in.) diameter; ovoid shape; Color: Imperial jade (21-L-12).

›FRUIT

On grafted trees the first fruit production occurred after two seasons. Internal characteristics: The fruit is commercially seedless in its normal cropping cycle. If the trees are manipulated to produce a summer flowering and hence a spring/summer crop (a Verdelli crop), then a low number of seeds may be present (less than 3 seeds per 15 fruit). Typical seed shape elliptical to ovoid. There is no persistence of the style on the fruit.

Internal characteristics: Flesh color: Near rind, yellow (17-L-1); Remainder, yellow (17-L-1). Interior segments: Average of 9 to 10 in number. Interior segment membranes — Thin. Pulp vesicles: Medium, 6-8 mm (0.24-0.32 in.) length; 2 mm (0.08 in.) diameter; color: yellow (17-L-1). The septa: Dorsal convex contoured character. Juice — abundant in mature fruit, evenly distributed in sections, typical lemon flavor: rich, with high acid and low sugar, well blended (pH of 3-3.7). The fruit center is complete without separation. Rind oil cells are medium to large, and occur at a density of approximately 30-50 per cm 2 . Oil — 0.6-0.7% (approx. 655 g oil/100 kg fruit). Glandular layer 2-3 mm (0.08-0.12 in.). Mesocarp (albedo) — 5-8 mm (0.2-0.32 in.). Axis: 5-6 mm (0.2-0.24 in.) diameter. Fruit weight: Average of 110 g-130 g (mean of 100 fruit per tree and 5 trees). Date of maturity: Southeast Turkey: about August 15 th . Riverside, Calif.: about August 25 th . External characteristics: Size: Medium.

Length.— 60-70 mm (2.36-2.76 in.). Width.— 50-60 mm (1.97-2.36 in.).

Form: Round to slightly oval elliptical. Fruit surface — smooth. Basal (stem end) even to slightly raised. Base: Diameter 12-14 mm (0.48-0.56 in.). Stem: Length: 10-12 mm (0.4-0.48 in.). Calyx: Diameter 5-8 mm (0.2-0.32 in.). Apex: Slightly raised, distinctly nippled. Aerole: Diameter 1-2 mm (0.04-0.08 in.). Style scar: Yes, diameter 1-2 mm (0.04-0.08 in.). Rind: Surface — smooth. Thickness — average 3-4 mm (0.12-0.16 in.). Color: Verdure (22-A-12) at first harvest (August) developing to a deep yellow (17-L-1) by the end of November. Internal fruit quality acceptability occurs approximately at the onset of temperature-induced color change. The fruit color changes to a bud green (19-K-10). At full color development the fruit has a uniform yellow hue (around 17-L-1).

The above description of this new variety of lemon is based on the growing conditions prevalent in the southeast area of Turkey and in Riverside, Calif. variations of the usual magnitude, such as differences in maturity date and production, may be due to cultural practices including irrigation, fertilization, pruning, fruit thinning and primary climate changes as well as soil conditions.

Use. —Fresh market/juice/oil extraction. Keeping quality. —Excellent (stores for 6 months in controlled atmosphere. First harvest date. —Around August 15 th in southeast Turkey; around August 25 th in Southern California

Post harvest disorders are similar to existing lemon varieties. In post harvest storage trials under standard controlled atmosphere conditions, the ‘Limoneira Seedless’ could be economically stored, with minimal fruit loss for at least 6 months.

Table 1 below compares the fruit skin color, seeds and pollen fertility between fruit harvested from the ‘Limoneira Seedless’ as compared to ‘Interdonato’ on Sep. 14, 2002:

Table 2 details some preliminary yield data for grafted trees. Table 3 compares fruit juice and acid content for the ‘Limoneira Seedless’ lemon as compared to ‘Interdonato’ lemons for the 2002-2003 season. Measurements in each case were carried out on 10 fruit per tree and a 5 tree sample giving a total of a 50 fruit sample. Table 2 indicates the typical yield on grafted trees is as follows:

The Adana region of Turkey grows many similar varieties of citrus to those grown in California. As a comparison harvest times of certain common citrus varieties growing in the two regions are listed in Table 5 below:

›Tables in the description — 5
TABLE 1
Fruit skin colorSeeds/fruit*Pollen
Tree(Sep. 14, 2002)(Sep. 14, 2002)fertility**
InterdonatoShamrock Gr3-685%
(19-L-12)
Limoneira SeedlessSpring Gr<13-5%
(18-J-7)
*100 fruit assessed per tree, 5 trees
**Estimated by acetocarmine staining during flowering in April
TABLE 2 — Typical Yield
YearYield
Yr 10
Yr 245 kg
Yr 395 kg
Yr 4150 kg
TABLE 3 — Fruit Acid
‘Limoneira Seedless’‘Interdonato’
AcidAcid (meq/Juice
Date(meq/100 g)Juice %100 g) %
August 15 th103329724
August 30 th1073110125
September 15 th10534.510024.5
September 30 th1113610726
October 15 th11037.510825
October 30 th11238.511027
November 15 th1154011230
November 30 th11441.511732
TABLE 4 — Typical Picking Pattern of the ‘Limoneira Seedless’ Lemon in Adana, Turkey
First Pick:15-20% of totalMid August
Second Pick30-40% of totalMid October
Third Pick30% of totalEarly December
Fourth Pick20% of totalFebruary
TABLE 5 — *fruit is allowed to hang to the following year. **Harvest time in the Southern Central Valley of California based on the harvest time of other citrus varieties.
VarietyAdana,Riverside,
(all unpatented)TurkeyCalifornia (USA)
Meyer Lemonweek 36 to week 45week 38 to week 48
Lisbon Lemonweek 38 to week 50week 40 to week 20*
Nules Clementineweek 46 to week 48week 43 to week 45
Washington Navelweek 46 to week 50week 46 to week 52
Minneola tangeloweek 50 to week 12*week 1-week 14*
Valencia Orangeweek 18 to week 24*week 18 to week 28*
Limoneira Seedlessweek 34 to week 16*week 36 to week 20**
Lemon
1 of 12 part labels are ours — the grant heads the rest

Claims

1 · 1 independent · depth 1
1 granted claims

Classifications

2 codes
IPC · International Patent Classification
Section A — Human necessities
  • A01H5/08
USPC · US Patent Classification
PLT/201

Claim changes

Soon
Coming soonHow the claims changed between publication and grant

See which claims were amended, added or cancelled during examination, with every added and removed word marked.

AmendedAddedCancelledUnchanged

The published claims of this patent are not paired with the granted ones in what we hold.

File wrapper

Pendency
2.1 y
783 days filing → grant
Office actions
1
non-final + final
Responses
1
no RCE
Examiner
Kent L. Bell
art unit 1661 · TC 1600
Citations: 1 back · 0 forward

See the full prosecution history — every USPTO and applicant action on this file, in order.

Log in to unlock

Chain of title

⤢ drag to zoom2006200820102012201420162018202020222024Owner 1
Titlehover for detail · click to open

See the full assignment history — every owner this patent has passed through, with recordation dates and reel/frame numbers.

Log in to unlock

Term & fees

See the term timeline — pendency span, in-force span, the maintenance fees paid and both computed expiry dates.

Log in to unlock

Priority chain

1 priority documents
›Priority documents — 1
TypeDocumentDate
related publicationUS 20060179523 P110 Aug 2006

Validity challenges

See the validity challenges on record — reexaminations, IPRs and PGRs, with their institution decisions and outcomes.

Log in to unlock

Citations

See every patent this one cites and every patent that cites it back — publication, assignee, and how each one was found.

Log in to unlock