Rare-earth metal halide scintillators with reduced hygroscopicity and method of making the same

This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Applications Ser. Nos. 61/545,253 and 61/545,262, both filed Oct. 10, 2011, which provisional applications are incorporated herein by reference.

This disclosure relates to scintillator materials used for detecting ionizing radiation, such as X-rays, gamma rays and thermal neutron radiation, in security, medical imaging, particle physics and other applications. This disclosure relates particularly to rare-earth metal halide scintillator materials. Certain arrangements also relate to specific compositions of such scintillator material, method of making the same and devices with such scintillator materials as components.

Scintillator materials, which emit light pulses in response to impinging radiation, such as X-rays, gamma rays and thermal neutron radiation, are used in detectors that have a wide range of applications in medical imaging, particle physics, geological exploration, security and other related areas. Considerations in selecting scintillator materials typically include, but are not limited to, luminosity, decay time, emission wavelengths, and stability of the scintillation material in the intended environment.

While a variety of scintillator materials have been made, there is a continuous need for superior scintillator materials.

Metal Halides, especially rare earth metal halides such as LaBr 3 , LaCl 3 , CeBr 3 , CeCl 3 and LuI 3 , are scintillator compositions known from their good energy resolution and relatively high light output. The main disadvantage of these materials is their extremely high solubility in water. Hygroscopicity is one of the main reasons that slows down the process of commercialization of these compounds. Crystal growth processes, following a multistage purification, zone refining and drying all require very well controlled atmosphere with depleted content of water and oxygen. Moreover, handling and post-growth processing of these materials has to be performed in an ultra-dry environment to avoid degradation of materials. Furthermore, many of these compounds are light sensitive and thus require additional handling steps. In addition, such materials often can be used only in the hermetic package that prevents them from degradation due to the hydration effects. Therefore, it is desirable to improve or develop new scintillator materials with significantly lower solubility in water (i.e., lower hygroscopicity).

This disclosure relates generally to rare-earth metal halide scintillator materials and method of making such scintillator materials. In one arrangement, the rare-earth metal halide scintillator materials have compositions with reduced hygroscopicity. Compositions in specific implementations include three group of elements: Lanthanides, (La, Ce, Lu, Gd or V), elements in group 17 of the periodic table of elements (CI, Br and I) and elements of group 13 (B, AI, Ga, In, TI), and any combination of these elements.

A further aspect of the present disclosure relates to a method of making chloride scintillator materials of the above-mentioned compositions. In one example, high-purity starting halides (such as TlBr and CeBr 3 ) are mixed and melted to synthesize a compound of the desired composition of the scintillator material. A single crystal of the scintillator material is then grown from the synthesized compound by the Bridgman method (or Vertical Gradient Freeze (VGF) method), in which a sealed ampoule containing the synthesized compound is transported from a hot zone to a cold zone through a controlled temperature gradient at a controlled speed to form a single-crystalline scintillator from molten synthesized compound.

Another aspect of the present disclosure relates to a method of using a detector comprising one of the scintillation materials described above for imaging.

This disclosure is related to the new compositions of rare earth metal halides where the change in the character of the compounds is achieved by adding of elements from group 13 of Periodic Table of Elements. These elements may create covalent bonds with metal halides that result in their lower hygroscopicity. A good example of group-13 compounds is TlBr, which is known for being insoluble in water. Introduction of Tl into the rare earth metal halides, such as LaBr 3 and CeBr 3 , results in creation of TI-Br covalent bonds. These bonds change the character of these compounds from being “Hard Acid-Hard Base” to “Soft Acid-Soft Base.”

The physical forms of the scintillator substance include, but are not limited to, crystal, polycrystalline, ceramic, powder or any of composite forms of the material.

A reduction in the hygroscopicity is achieved by co-doping and/or changes in the stoichiometry of a scintillator substance. These changes may be achieved by stoichiometric admixture and/or solid solution of compounds containing elements from group-13 periodic table.

One way of the implementation of this innovation is a codoping with one or more group-13 elements in concentrations that do not alter significantly the symmetry of the crystal lattice of the scintillator of choice. Another way includes a complete modification of the crystal structure of the scintillator composition by stoichiometric change or solid solution of scintillator compounds and other compounds containing at least one of group-13 elements. In these cases, new scintillator materials are created with significantly reduced hygroscopicity.

The present disclosure includes, but is not being limited to, the following families of metal halides compositions described by general chemical formulas:

A′ (1−x) B′ x Ca (1−y) Eu y C′ 3 (1),

A′ 3(1−x) B′ 3x M′Br 6(1−y) Cl 6y (2),

A′ (1−x) B′ x M′ 2 Br 7(1−y) C′ 7y (3),

A′ (1−x) B′ x M″ (1−y) Eu y I 3 (4),

A′ 3(1−x) B′ 3x M″ (1−y) Eu y I 5 (5),

A′ (1−x) B′ x M″ 2(1−y) Eu 2y I 5 (6),

A′ 3(1−x) B′ 3x M′ 2 Cl 7 (7),

A′ (1−x) B′ x M′ 2 Cl 7 (8), and

M′ (1−x) B′ x C′ 3 (9),

wherein:

A′=Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs or any combination thereof,

B′=B, Al, Ga, In, Tl or any combination thereof,

C′=Cl, Br, I or any combination thereof,

M′ consist of Ce, Sc, Y, La, Lu, Gd, Pr, Tb, Yb, Nd or any combination thereof,

M″ consists of Sr, Ca, Ba or any combination of thereof,

0≤x≤1, and

0≤y≤1.

In a particular, non-limiting, example, thallium (Tl) is introduced into the crystallographic lattice of LaBr 3 compound (formula 9). In this specific example, a strong Tl—Br covalent bond (as opposed to ionic bond in LaBr 3 ) is created that significantly reduces the reactivity of the compound with water.

In the higher concentration of Tl it is possible to create scintillator materials with altered crystallographic lattice. That includes also a stoichiometry change in the crystal itself. The strength of Tl—Br bond is demonstrated in TlBr compound that is known from significantly lower hygroscopicity in comparison to the other rare-earth metal halides. The expected changes in solubility can be explained based on the HSAB concept, explained in more detail below.

Moreover, introduction of the elements from group-13 into the crystal structure of rare-earth metal halides often improves scintillation characteristics of these materials. Addition of Tl as a codopant or stoichiometric admixture to certain compositions of rare-earth metal halides creates very efficient scintillation centers. These centers contribute to the scintillation light output.

In addition, using compounds of group-13 elements can favorably increase the density of the material. Improvement in the density is particularly important in radiation detection applications. The new scintillator materials have applications in Positron Emission Tomography (PET), Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT), Computerized Tomography (CT), and other applications used in homeland security and well logging industry.

This disclosure also relates to the method of growing scintillator that includes crystallization of the melted or dissolved scintillator compounds under controlled environment.

The changes in solubility of new rare-earth metal halides scintillators disclosed herein may be understood based on HSAB concept.

The HSAB is an acronym for “Hard and Soft Acids and Bases” known also, as the Pearson acid-base concept. This concept attempts to unify inorganic and organic reaction chemistry and can be used to explain in qualitative rather than quantitative way the stability of compounds, reaction mechanisms and pathways. The concept assigns the terms ‘hard’ or ‘soft’, and ‘acid’ or ‘base’ to variety of chemical species. ‘Hard’ applies to species which are small based on their Ionic radii, have high charge states (the charge criterion applies mainly to acids, to a lesser extent to bases), and are weakly polarizable. ‘Soft’ applies to species which are big, have low charge states and are strongly polarizable. Polarizable species can form covalent bonds, whereas non-polarizable form ionic bonds. See, for example, (1) Jolly, W. L., Modern Inorganic Chemistry, New York: McGraw-Hill (1984); and (2) E.-C. Koch, Acid-Base Interactions in Energetic Materials: I. The Hard and Soft Acids and Bases (HSAB) Principle-Insights to Reactivity and Sensitivity of Energetic Materials, Prop., Expl., Pyrotech. 30 2005, 5. Both of the references are incorporated herein by reference.

In the context of this disclosure the HSAB theory helps in understanding the predominant factors which drive chemical properties and reactions. In this case, the qualitative factor is solubility in water. On the one hand, water is a hard acid and hard base combination, so it is compatible with hard acid and bases. Thallium bromide is, on another hand, a soft acid and soft base combination, so it is not soluble in water.

According to the HSAB theory, soft acids react faster and form stronger bonds with soft bases, whereas hard acids react faster and form stronger bonds with hard bases, all other factors being equal.

Hard acids and hard bases tend to have the following characteristics:

small atomic/ionic radius high oxidation state low polarlzabllity high electronegativity (bases)

Examples of hard acids include: H + , light alkali ions (for example, Li through K all have small ionic radius), Ti 4+ , Cr 3+ , Cr6+ , BF 3 . Examples of hard bases are: OH − , F − , Cl − , NH 3 , CH 3 COO − and CO 3 2− . The affinity of hard acids and hard bases for each other is mainly ionic in nature.

Soft acids and soft bases tend to have the following characteristics:

large atomic/ionic radius low or zero oxidation state high polarizability low electronegativity

Examples of soft acids are: CH 3 Hg + , Pt 2+ , Ag + , Au + , Hg 2+ , Hg 2 2+ , Cd 2+ , BH 3 and group-13 in +1 oxidation state. Examples of soft bases include: H − , R 3 P, SCN − and I − . The affinity of soft acids and bases for each other is mainly covalent in nature.

There are also borderline cases identified as borderline acids for example: trimethylborane, sulfur dioxide and ferrous Fe 2+ , cobalt Co 2+ , cesium Cs + and lead Pb 2+ cations, and borderline bases such as bromine, nitrate and sulfate anions.

Generally speaking, acids and bases interact and the most stable interactions are hard-hard (ionogenic character) and soft-soft (covalent character).

In the specific case presented as an example compounds such as LaBr 3 and TlBr have the following elements to consider following reaction with water: La +3 , Br − , Tl + , H − , OH − .

La +3 : This is a strong acid. High positive charge (+3) small ionic radius. Br − : This is a soft base. Large ionic radius small charge (−1). Tl + : This is a soft acid. Low charge and large ionic radius. H + : This is a hard acid. Low ionic radius and high charge density. OH − : This is a hard base. Low charge, small ionic radius.

Thus the reaction of LaBr 3 and water takes place in according to the following scheme:

[La +3 ,Br − ]+[H + , OH − ]→[La +3 , OH − ]+[H + , Br].

The left hand side of the equation has two components that are being mixed. The right hand side represents products after mixing. One can see that the strong acid La +3 with the strong base OH − , are joined together because it makes a strong acid and base combination. The Br − is driven from the La +3 and thus it is complexed with H + , forming hydrobromic acid.

The reaction of TlBr with water following the scheme:

[Tl + ,Br − ]+[H + , OH − ]→[Tl + , Br − ]+[H + , OH − ].

In this case, Tl + and Br − are favored because they are a combination of soft-soft acid and base. While the H + and OH − are hard acid and base combination. The TlBr is a covalent compound and will dissolve in covalent solvents.

Therefore, in the case of LaBr 3 , the hard acid La +3 “seeks” out OH − , resulting in a high reactivity in water. In contrast, TlBr (soft-soft) does not “seek” water (and vice versa). The result is a low degree of interaction, including solubility with water.

In the examples given above in this disclosure, the addition of TlBr as a co-dopant or in stoichiometric amounts reduces the hygroscopicity of the LaBr 3 .

A further aspect of the present disclosure relates to a method of making scintillator materials of the above-mentioned compositions. In one example, high-purity starting compounds (such as LaBr 3 and TlBr) are mixed and melted to synthesize a compound of the desired composition of the scintillator material. A single crystal of the scintillator material is then grown from the synthesized compound by the Bridgman method (or Vertical Gradient Freeze (VGF) method), in which a sealed ampoule containing the synthesized compound is transported from a hot zone to a cold zone through a controlled temperature gradient at a controlled speed to form a single-crystalline scintillator from molten synthesized compound.

Thus, rare-earth metal halide scintillation materials with improved moisture resistance, density and/or light output can be made with the addition of group-13 elements such as Tl. Because many embodiments of the invention can be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention, the invention resides in the claims hereinafter appended.