Fresh From the Bench: Latest Federal Circuit Court Cases
Contributed by Schwabe Williamson & Wyatt. Originally published on Patexia; republished here as part of the LexDana archive.
CASE OF THE WEEK
Impax Laboratories Inc. v. Lannett Holdings Inc., Appeal No. 2017-2020 (Fed. Cir. June 28, 2018)
In an appeal taken from the Delaware district court, the Federal Circuit extended deference to the district court’s decision to uphold validity of two patents despite a specific, albeit brief, teaching of the claimed pharmaceutical formulation in a prior art reference. The patents at issue claimed formulations for intranasal administration of having zolmitriptan as the active ingredient. The Federal Circuit affirmed the district court’s decision that a second prior art reference “taught away” from the claimed formulation by teaching that a metabolite of zolmitriptan was more effective than zolmitriptan for intranasal applications. Though it found this to be a “close case,” the appellate court found that under the deferential “clearly erroneous” standard of review, the district court’s ruling had sufficient support in the evidence to avoid reversal.
Written by: Scott Eads and Nika F. Aldrich, Schwabe, Williamson & Wyatt
Contributors: Cristin Wagner
More insights
Federal Circuit Affirms Invalidation of Patent for Lack of Enablement of Claims Directed to a Method of Treating a Patient with a Unit Dosage in Wyeth Llc v Astrazeneca Pharmaceuticals Lp
Written by : Eric Furman, Ph.D. and Ashley C. Morales Key Takeaway: Federal Circuit invalidates patent claims directed to a method for treating non-small cell lung cancer through administration of “a unit dosage” of an irreversible epidermal…
When About Becomes Indefinite Federal Circuit Provides Guidance for Life Science Patent Applications Regarding Limits of Approximation in Enviro Tech v Safe Foods
Written by : Jason J. Jardine and Kenneth O. Aruda, Ph.D. Key Takeaway: The term “about” remains useful in biotech and pharmaceutical claims, but only if the patent provides objective guidance about what the term means. Absent that guidance,…
When Any Patent Means No Patent Federal Circuit Reverses Non Specific Verdict
Written by : Brian C. Barnes and Sophia F. Zahn OLLNOVA TECHNOLOGIES LTD. v. ECOBEE TECHNOLOGIES ULC [OPINION] Before Chen , Cunningham, and Stark. Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas. Summary : A verdict form…