Early Stage Patent Infringements (May 9, 2011)
Last week, there were over 30 new patent infringement lawsuits filed in the US:
1. Pragmatus AV, LLC v. Facebook, Inc.
Case: 5:11-cv-02168 filed on 5/6/2011 in Northern District of California
Plaintiff(s): Pragmatus AV, LLC
Defendant(s): Facebook, Inc.
Patent(s): 7,421,470 - Method for real-time communication between plural users
7,433,921 - System for real-time communication between plural users
2. Atticus Research Corporation v. VMware, Inc. et. al.
Case: 4:11-cv-01741 filed on 5/6/2011 in Southern District of Texas
Plaintiff(s): Atticus Research Corporation
Defendant(s): VMware, Inc. Springsource Inc. OSS Management Holdings, Inc.
Patent(s): 6567937 - Technique for remote state notification and software fault recovery
3. Erbe USA, Inc. v. Byrne Medical, Inc.
Case: 1:11-cv-0148 filed on 5/6/2011 in Northern District of Georgia
Plaintiff(s): Erbe USA, Inc.
Defendant(s): Byrne Medical, Inc.
Patent(s): 6210322 - Adapter for the connection of a water bottle to an endoscope
4. SIPCO, LLC v. ADT Security Services, Inc.
Case: 9:11-cv-80521 filed on 5/6/2011 in Southern District of Florida
Plaintiff(s): SIPCO, LLC
Defendant(s): ADT Security Services, Inc.
Patent(s): 6437692 - System and method for monitoring and controlling remote devices
5. Pollution Control Corporation v. Renegade Oilfield Products LLC
Case: 5:11-cv-00494 filed on 5/6/2011 in Western District of Oklahoma
Plaintiff(s): Pollution Control Corporation
Defendant(s): Renegade Oilfield Products LLC
Patent(s): 7,921,884
7,673,658 - Load line connection spillage container
5,647,412 - Apparatus for containing oil and waste spillage at a line connection
6. Drivecam, Inc. v. Smartdrive Systems, Inc.
Case: 3:11-cv-00997 filed on 5/6/2011 in Southern District of California
Plaintiff(s): Drivecam, Inc.
Defendant(s): Smartdrive Systems, Inc.
Patent(s): 6,389,340 - Vehicle data recorder
7,804,426 - System and method for selective review of event data
7,659,827 - System and method for taking risk out of driving
7. G-P Moves Freight, LLC v. J.B. Hunt Transport Services, Inc. et. al.
Case: 5:11-cv-00099 filed on 5/6/2011 in Eastern District of Texas
Plaintiff(s): G-P Moves Freight, LLC
Defendant(s): J.B. Hunt Transport Services, Inc. Schneider National, Inc.
Patent(s): 7854577
8. Bianca Lucas et. al. v. Deborah Camacho et. al.
Case: 3:11-cv-05350 filed on 5/5/2011 in Western District of Washington
Plaintiff(s): Bianca Lucas CB Stormwater LLC Dr. Chassidy F Lucas
Defendant(s): Deborah Camacho Ali Parker Angela Stephenson George Parker Joe Camacho
Patent(s): 7771591 - Filter system for catch basins
9. Eli Lilly and Company v. Zydus Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc.
Case: 2:11-cv-02582 filed on 5/5/2011 in District of New Jersey
Plaintiff(s): Eli Lilly and Company
Defendant(s): Zydus Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc.
Patent(s): 5658590 - Treatment of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder
10. Millipore Corporation et. al. v. I.W. Tremont Co. Inc.
Case: 1:11-cv-10787 filed on 5/5/2011 in District of Massachusetts
Plaintiff(s): Millipore Corporation Millipore S.A.S.
Defendant(s): I.W. Tremont Co. Inc.
Patent(s): 5448874 - Method and apparatus for removing objects from sterile packaging
11. ING Bank, fsb v. N99 LLC et. al.
Case: 1:11-cv-00398 filed on 5/5/2011 in District of Delaware
Plaintiff(s): ING Bank, fsb
Defendant(s): N99 LLC Cascades Branding Innovation LLC
Patent(s): 7768395 - Brand mapping
12. GHJ Holdings, LLC v. Grindmaster-Cecilware Corporation
Case: 5:11-cv-00098 filed on 5/5/2011 in Eastern District of Texas
Plaintiff(s): GHJ Holdings, LLC
Defendant(s): Grindmaster-Cecilware Corporation
Patent(s): 4,878,625 - Bean and nut grinder shift mechanism
4,794,853 - Universal brew basket support arms
13. Mixing & Mass Transfer Technologies, LLC v. HDR, Inc. et. al.
Case: 4:11-cv-03068 filed on 5/5/2011 in District of Nebraska
Plaintiff(s): Mixing & Mass Transfer Technologies, LLC
Defendant(s): HDR, Inc. City of Lincoln
Patent(s): 5811009 - Method and system for improved biological nitrification of wastewater at low temperature
14. Kletschka Foundation v. Levitronix, LLC
Case: 0:11-cv-01173 filed on 5/5/2011 in District of Minnesota
Plaintiff(s): Kletschka Foundation
Defendant(s): Levitronix, LLC
Patent(s): 5470208 - Fluid pump with magnetically levitated impeller
15. Erik B. Cherdak v. Crocs, Inc.
Case: 1:11-cv-00480 filed on 5/4/2011 in Eastern District of Virginia
Plaintiff(s): Erik B. Cherdak
Defendant(s): Crocs, Inc.
Patent(s): 5343445 - Athletic shoe with timing device
16. Jet Imports LLC v. HJC I, LLC
Case: 2:11-cv-00709 filed on 5/4/2011 in District of Nevada
Plaintiff(s): Jet Imports LLC
Defendant(s): HJC I, LLC
Patent(s): 7395930 - Tennis bag
17. Schrader-Bridgeport International, Inc. et. al. v. Continental Automotive Systems US, Inc.
Case: 6:11-cv-00014 filed on 5/4/2011 in Western District of Virginia
Plaintiff(s): Schrader-Bridgeport International, Inc. Schrader Electronics, Inc.
Defendant(s): Continental Automotive Systems US, Inc.
Patent(s): 7518495 - Universal tire pressure monitor
18. Lochner Technologies, LLC v. AT Labs Inc. et. al.
Case: 2:11-cv-00242 filed on 5/4/2011 in Eastern District of Texas
Plaintiff(s): Lochner Technologies, LLC
Defendant(s): AT Labs Inc. Boundless Technologies, Inc. CLI, Inc. Devon IT Inc. DT Research, Inc. IGEL Technology America, LLC I-O Corp. NCS Technologies, Inc. Ringdale, Inc. Symbio Technologies LLC TeleVideo, Inc. Z-Axis, Inc. 10ZiG Technology Inc.
Patent(s): 7035598 - Modular computer system
19. Promote Innovation LLC v. Bristol-Myers Squibb Company
Case: 3:11-cv-02535 filed on 5/4/2011 in District of New Jersey
Plaintiff(s): Promote Innovation LLC
Defendant(s): Bristol-Myers Squibb Company
Patent(s): 4978655 - Use of 3-deoxythymidin-2-ene (3deoxy-2,3-didehydrothymidine) in treating patients infected with retroviruses
20. Quality Edge, Inc. v. U.S. Aluminum, Inc.
Case: 1:11-cv-00453 filed on 5/3/2011 in Western District of Michigan
Plaintiff(s): Quality Edge, Inc.
Defendant(s): U.S. Aluminum, Inc.
Patent(s): 7,506,476 - Rain gutter guard and method
7,854,576
7,584,576 - Rain gutter guard and method
21. Lori Braun et. al. v. Dr. Dennis Gross Skincare, LLC
Case: 2:11-cv-00703 filed on 5/3/2011 in District of Nevada
Plaintiff(s): Lori Braun Lori Braun Family Trust
Defendant(s): Dr. Dennis Gross Skincare, LLC
Patent(s): 5972360 - Self-tanning towelette
22. Dako Denmark A/S et. al. v. Leica Microsystems Inc. et. al.
Case: 1:11-cv-00390 filed on 5/3/2011 in District of Delaware
Plaintiff(s): Dako Denmark A/S Dako North America Inc.
Defendant(s): Leica Microsystems Inc. Leica Microsystems
Patent(s): 7,217,392 - Random access slide stainer with independent slide heating regulation
7,553,672 - Random access slide stainer with independent slide heating regulation
6,541,261 - Method using a slide stainer with independent slide heating regulation
6,183,693 - Random access slide stainer with independent slide heating regulation
23. Syndrome Distribution, Inc. v. TGM Distribution, Inc.
Case: 3:11-cv-00945 filed on 5/3/2011 in Southern District of California
Plaintiff(s): Syndrome Distribution, Inc.
Defendant(s): TGM Distribution, Inc.
Patent(s): 6279434 - Skateboard tool
24. Crayola LLC v. C2C Technologies LLC
Case: 1:11-cv-00389 filed on 5/3/2011 in District of Delaware
Plaintiff(s): Crayola LLC
Defendant(s): C2C Technologies LLC
Patent(s): 5,664,947 - Method, apparatus, and kit for marking a surface with colored bubbles
7,910,531
4,511,497 - Bubble composition using multipurpose surfactant base
25. Value-Security Company, LLC v. Aegon Direct Marketing Services, Inc. et. al.
Case: 1:11-cv-01164 filed on 5/3/2011 in District of Maryland
Plaintiff(s): Value-Security Company, LLC
Defendant(s): Aegon Direct Marketing Services, Inc. Transamerica Corporation
Patent(s): 7370000 - System and method for providing additional insurance
26. Novartis AG et. al. v. David J. Kappos
Case: 1:11-cv-00821 filed on 5/3/2011 in District Of Columbia
Plaintiff(s): Novartis AG Novartis Corporation
Defendant(s): David J. Kappos
Patent(s): 7,081,532 - N-phenyl-2-pyrimidine-amine derivatives
7,323,451 - Crystalline and amorphous forms of beta-L-2′-deoxythymidine
7,687,637 - 5-phenylthiazole derivatives and use as Pi3 kinase inhibitors
7,097,827
27. FourthWall Media Inc. v. Submedia Europe et. al.
Case: 1:11-cv-00823 filed on 5/3/2011 in District Of Columbia
Plaintiff(s): FourthWall Media Inc.
Defendant(s): Submedia Europe Mehmet R. Aras
Patent(s): 7036139 - Method and apparatus for remote control of a distributed television broadcasting system
28. Kirker Enterprises Inc. v. Expression Beauty Works Inc. et. al.
Case: 2:11-cv-02541 filed on 5/3/2011 in District of New Jersey
Plaintiff(s): Kirker Enterprises Inc.
Defendant(s): Expression Beauty Works Inc. De Roblin Inc. Layla Cosmetics SRL
Patent(s): 5935590 - Fingernail lacquer composition and method of application
29. GT Nexus, Inc. v. Inttra Inc.
Case: 3:11-cv-02145 filed on 5/3/2011 in Northern District of California
Plaintiff(s): GT Nexus, Inc.
Defendant(s): Inttra Inc.
Patent(s): 7,827,119
7,752,142 - Common carrier system
7,756,794 - Common carrier system
7,761,387 - Common carrier system
30. Takeda Pharmaceutical Company Ltd. et. al. v. Mylan Inc. et. al.
Case: 3:11-cv-02506 filed on 5/2/2011 in District of New Jersey
Plaintiff(s): Takeda Pharmaceutical Company Ltd. Takeda Pharmaceuticals North America Inc. Takeda Pharmaceuticals LLC Takeda Pharmaceuticals America Inc. Ethypharm SA
Defendant(s): Mylan Inc. Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc.
Patent(s): 6,328,994 - Orally disintegrable tablets
5,464,632 - Rapidly disintegratable multiparticular tablet
31. Jazz Pharmaceuticals Inc. v. Roxane Laboratories, Inc.
Case: 2:11-cv-02523 filed on 5/2/2011 in District of New Jersey
Plaintiff(s): Jazz Pharmaceuticals Inc.
Defendant(s): Roxane Laboratories, Inc.
Patent(s): 7,851,506
6,472,431
32. DR Systems, Inc. v. Avreo, Inc. et. al.
Case: 3:11-cv-00932 filed on 5/2/2011 in Southern District of California
Plaintiff(s): DR Systems, Inc.
Defendant(s): Avreo, Inc. Candelis, Inc. Cerner Corporation Coactiv, LLC Connect Imaging, Inc. Computer Programs and Systems, Inc. iCRCO, Inc. Infinitt North America, Inc. Medweb California, LLC Penrad Technologies, Inc. Radiology Information Systems, Inc. Ramsoft USA, Inc. Sectra North America, Inc. Thinking Systems Corporation Visage Imaging, Inc. Visus USA, LLC
Patent(s): 5452416 - Automated system and a method for organizing, presenting, and manipulating medical images
33. Atwater Partners of Texas LLC v. Actelis Networks, Inc. et. al.
Case: 1:11-cv-00387 filed on 5/2/2011 in District of Delaware
Plaintiff(s): Atwater Partners of Texas LLC
Defendant(s): Actelis Networks, Inc. Adaptive Spectrum and Signal Alignment, Inc. Conexant Systems, Inc. Ericsson Ericsson Inc. Ethernity Networks Ltd Ethernity Networks Ikanos Communications, Inc. Nokia Siemens Networks US LLC Pace Americas, Inc. Positron Access Solutions Inc. RAD Data Communications, Inc.
Patent(s): 6490296 - Multi-link segmentation and reassembly for bonding multiple PVCs in an inverse multiplexing arrangement
34. C.F. Stinson, Inc. et. al. v. Mayer-Paetz, Inc.
Case: 2:11-cv-11926 filed on 5/2/2011 in Eastern District of Michigan
Plaintiff(s): C.F. Stinson, Inc. Sample Technologies, LLC
Defendant(s): Mayer-Paetz, Inc.
Patent(s): 7249035 - Method and system for presenting custom-labeled surface material samples over a computer network
35. Calvin T. Switzer v. Litex Industries Ltd. et. al.
Case: 1:11-cv-01174 filed on 5/2/2011 in District of Colorado
Plaintiff(s): Calvin T. Switzer
Defendant(s): Litex Industries Ltd. Lowe's Companies, Inc. Costco Wholesaler Corporation Amazon.com, Inc. Shopzeus.com, LLC
Patent(s): 7,837,509
7,837,508
36. Hunts Point Ventures, Inc. v. digEcor, Inc.
Case: 3:11-cv-00319 filed on 5/2/2011 in Western District of Wisconsin
Plaintiff(s): Hunts Point Ventures, Inc.
Defendant(s): digEcor, Inc.
Patent(s): 7574272 - System and method for data transfer optimization in a portable audio device
More insights
Structuring Solar IP Claims for Leverage: How System Claims and Induced or Contributory Infringement Can Expand Enforcement Options
Written by: Tyler S. Cox Key Takeaways: Nextpower’s mix of apparatus and system claims illustrates how claim strategy can expand enforcement flexibility. Additionally, carefully drafting patent claims can expand the scope of protection of the claim…

Patexia Insight 256: Patent Litigation Remains Concentrated in Key U.S. District Courts
U.S. District Court patent litigation continues to be one of the most consequential and data-rich arenas in intellectual property enforcement. Between July 1, 2020, and June 30, 2025, 18,352 patent cases were filed across federal courts, involving tens of…

Litigation Finance Tax Dropped From Trump S Big Beautiful Bill
In a major development for the billion dollar litigation finance industry, a tax provision targeting litigation funders has been removed from President Trump’s sweeping tax and spending legislation, dubbed the “Big, Beautiful Bill”,…